Last night I decided to continue my Steak Quest to find the best steakhouse in DFW.
So, here’s an update:
- We’ve already determined through internal discussions that Ft. Worth isn’t included in this search because it’s just too freakin’ far. Sorry, maybe next time.
- The first contestant was the Y.O. Ranch Steakhouse in downtown Dallas. I ate chips, meat, and pudding. It was splendid.
By taking an informal poll of everyone at our office and random, unsuspecting people on the street, here’s the entire list of steakhouses that’ll be subjected to my taste testing:
Y.O. Ranch Steakhouse (Already ate here.)
- Mignon
- Nick & Sam’s
- Bob’s Steak & Chop House
- Del Frisco’s
- Sullivan’s
- Three Forks
- Randy’s Steakhouse
- Chamberlain’s
I’ll try to visit them in that order, but that may change depending on the day, my mood, my credit score, or whatever. With that said, on with the reviews:
Yesterday took me to MIGNON in Plano, TX. They’re known for their seafood dishes and I just had to visit them after a friend insisted that it was undoubtedly one of the best, if not the best, steakhouses in DFW. I hope he’s right or somebody owes me gas money.
Instead of going alone, I brought along my best friend with promises of steak nirvana and other such false hopes. Plus, it’s always a blast to dress up and go to dinner with a close male friend and have most people assume you’re on a date. It’s this kind of social derangement that I live for.
We arrived around 8:00pm. The exterior of the restaurant resembled an old shoppe in France, complete with curvy typefaces, subtle paint, and molding.
We enter and are greeted quickly. Walking to our table, we pass the bar on our right. It’s adorned with glass, some nice textures, and has the typical liquor-bottles-as-trophies display. Do people really care how many types of tequila are on hand? I’ve always wondered this.
The rest of the restaurant is decorated in similar textures, and a combination of yellow, red, and brown color variations. We notice that some of the walls and columns are finished with a cool-colored, mosaic tile pattern, and we even notice a booth that has walls that resemble some sort of funky strawberry swirl. It’s an odd combination of features, but they all fit together very nicely. It’s classy without being tacky, and it’s all very, very French. Even the servers had accents.
We sit down and get right to business and order a couple of appetizers. First up, a plate of Bruschetta followed by Braised Beef Short Rib.
The Bruschetta was good, but nothing spectacular. It had a good paste (or spread), but the flavor was too subtle for me, and the red, green, and yellow cherry tomatoes that were supposed to compliment the dish seemed to overpower it. It’s a decent start, but there’s always hope, and we’re not exactly here to judge tomatoes. The Braised Beef Short Rib, which I actually ordered on an impulse, was an entirely different story. This appetizer was definitely not screwin’ around — the first bite was somewhat intoxicating. The beef was succulent, perfectly seasoned, and you could cut it with a fork. It sat atop a bed of garlic mash, also perfectly seasoned, with only a hint of gravy. The beef seemed to melt in my mouth and I just savored it like fine wine.
For the main course I ordered the Prime Grilled New York Steak (14oz). I would’ve gone with a top sirloin but Mignon doesn’t serve that cut of steak.
My steak arrives after a short wait. Just as in the Bruschetta and Short Rib, the dish was arranged and presented very nicely. It was like a dining scene right out of American Psycho’s Dorsia. It sat on a bed of Roasted Fingerling Potatoes and Green-Pepper Corn Brandy Sauce. The potatoes were nicely roasted, but the real kick came from the brandy sauce. I’m starting to see that it’s not uncommon to have the condiments on a dish be the star of the show, and this was no exception. I cut into the steak, and it’s cooked medium rare as I requested, a beautiful palette of red hues. At 14oz, it’s the biggest steak I’ve ever had. The outside is a nice dark brown, and the steak is thick enough that I can cut it into tall slices like one of those big-ass Thanksgiving hams. I take a bite and the Matrix tells me it’s juicy and delicious. Every time I put a slice in my mouth, I let it sit on my tongue while I absorb all the juices. It’s good, really good. With every bite it seems like the flavor of the steak matures, and it just keeps getting better and better. Once I’m halfway through, my stomach is full, but I continue eating anyway because wasting such a savory slab of meat is a social crime.
Overall, Mignon does a great job of creating a unique environment. That type of experience is something I rarely encounter in restaurants anymore. It’s not just about the good food and the ritzy wines, it’s about the French surroundings, the service, and the presentation. For two people with appetizers, a main course, and some liquor, it cost us about $140. It’s definitely pricey, but it’s definitely worth it. It’s time to forget your lame, usual Friday night eatery and put on some cufflinks and take your ass to Mignon!